Bring me to the Main Page   Bring me to the Reviews Index

Jack Nicklaus' Greatest 18 Holes Of Major Championship Golf 1989 logo

ACCOLADE £24.95 * Mouse

A Jack Nicklaus' Greatest 18 Holes Of Major Championship Golf 1989 golfing legend, winner of more major championships than anyone else, much demanded course designer and all-American hero: the Golden bear. A golf game cannot come with a much better endorsement than jack, but does it live up to his reputation?
Three courses are available: Castle Pines in Colorado, Desert Mountain in Arizona and Jack’s Greatest 18. The Greatest 18 are culled from some of the most famous courses in the world, such as St Andrews, Augusta, Pebble Beach and Royal Lytham.

One to four players can take part, any or all of whom can be computer controlled. There is a choice of several opponents of varying ability, including Jack himself, who is of course incredibly good. There is also a choice of game type: ‘stroke play’ or ‘skins’. In skins the players play for prize money on each hole, the prizes increasing as they go along. Stroke play is the usual score-per-stroke, with the overall score plus or minus par kind of system.

Before playing each hole you are given an overhead view of it, which can be called up again while playing. You also get Jack’s words of wisdom on the hole, then it is off to the tee, where the view is from behind the player, looking towards the green and the pin.
The club is selected from a driver, two woods, eight irons, two wedges and a putter. Once the club is chosen and the shot aimed, the tricky part of swinging the club has to be done. This is a matter of timing mouse clicks to initiate the swing, to stop the power bar going upwards and then to stop it going down (for the accuracy). Mistiming clicks will result on the upswing in shots going long or short and on the downswing in the ball hooking or slicing.

The computer players do everything automatically: and slowly too. A lot can be learnt from watching them, particularly if you have a similar shot to play. There are various factors affecting a shot – windspeed and direction, sand, slopes and rough. On the putting surface there are only breaks to cope with, but the aiming of putts is very tricky.
If you are not happy with your performance you can always go off to the driving range and the practice green, or even practice on a few individual holes.
Bob Wade

Amiga Format, Issue 3, October 1989, p.39

GRAPHICS AND SOUND
The courses are picturesque, with trees, bunkers and lakes making up some lovely views. The only problem is the terribly slow speed at which the graphics are drawn. The view is redrawn for every shot so there is a lot of hanging about waiting for it.
The sound is limited but what is there is good: some excellent sampled speech at the beginning and realistic hitting and bouncing noises during play.

JUDGEMENT
The slow speed of play is annoying but not terminally so: just chill out, relax and take your time playing. The three courses are challenging and dangerous and the opponents provide good competition. It is a game you will be playing for years to come: s long as the old back injury does not flare up again...

GRAPHICS 5
SOUND 2
INTELLECT 5
ADDICTION 6
OVERALL 78%



Jack Nicklaus' Greatest 18 Holes Of Major Championship Golf 1989 logo

Accolade
Price: £24.95

Jack Nicklaus' Greatest 18 Holes Of Major Championship Golf 1989 L ike basketball, there is no shortage of golf games on any machine, particularly the Amiga, which whilst being relatively young in hardware terms can count over half a dozen golf titles written for it already. Any addition for this reason has to be of good quality otherwise it's just going to be passed over. Jack Nicklaus is good enough to hold its own with the rest and, in some cases, better.

Accolade have chosen to go for an endorsement from one of the greatest golfers of all time to boost sales, but in truth its execution is strong enough to warrant it. After an initially worrying bout of disk swapping the game sets itself up with clear and precise options. These include choosing whether to play alone, against the computer (you can choose its skill level by selecting from a list of names which include pros, women pros, experts and beginners) and deciding which course to play. There are two from the US – Pine Springs and Desert Mountain, and, a specially put together round of big Jack's favorite holes around the world.

The gameplay is simple. You hit the ball simply by tapping the mouse button or the keyboard, once to start the swing, and once again to control it as the power bar at the side of the screen drops. Direction is manipulated by dragging a little guide ball at the top of the screen to the left or the right. A meter at the bottom show the direction and strength of any wind, and later, when you putt, it shows any break from the green. All this is performed swiftly and efficiently enabling you to concentrate on the game.

Graphically Jack Nicklaus is amongst the most impressive sports sims I have seen, with each individual course drawn out exactly, with natural features like waters and trees outlined and filled in using a large palette of colours. One drawback though is the amount of time it takes to generate the screen. Each time you change location the screen is slowly revealed as a windows pulls back. More annoyingly still, it has to access the disk if you want to see an overhead view (very useful) and then draw the screen again afterwards.

The golfer though, is very neatly illustrated and faultlessly animated as he swings cleanly through ball after ball in a way which would make even the Golden Bear himself envious. Sound, as is usual with these kind of sims is minimal, and although you get a nice thwack when you hit a second shot, you don't hear it when you drive for some reason. There's a generous round of applause when you sink a birdie too, but it would have been nice to hear some other sounds – the odd cheer, or shout of 'in the hole!'.

Compared to the like of World Class Leaderboard Accolade's version acquits itself impressively. There are some problems – the computer controlled opponent is agonizingly slow. I have some reservations about the putting too which doesn't work as well as it should, and there are some inexplicable mistakes when you play, but these are outweighed by the general playability and attractiveness of the product. Jack should be pleased.
Mike Pattenden

CU Amiga, September 1989, p.31

SOUND
GRAPHICS
PLAYABILITY
LASTABILITY
62%
90%
86%
85%
84%